How to find the work required to pump water out of a tank

Water near the bottom of a tank has farther to travel than water near the top. That means the lifting distance changes as we move through the water. We can handle that by finding the work for one thin slice, then adding the slices with an integral.

Build the work for one slice

Work is force times distance. If the liquid has mass density δ and a slice has volume ΔV, its mass is approximately δΔV and its weight is δgΔV. Multiplying that weight by the lifting distance gives the work for the slice.

ΔW≈δgΔV·d

Example: Empty a partially filled conical tank

An inverted circular cone is 10 m tall and has top radius 5 m. Water fills the bottom 7 m. We’ll pump it over the top rim, using water density 1,000 kg per cubic meter and g=9.8 meters per second squared.

A water slice inside an inverted conical tankA cross-section of a ten-meter-deep cone has top radius five meters. Blue water fills the bottom seven meters. A thin purple slice is a distance x below the rim, has radius r, and has thickness delta x.5 mx10 mrΔx
The blue surface is 7 m above the bottom. Each slice must be lifted the distance x to reach the rim.

Let x measure distance downward from the rim. The top of the water is at x=3, and the bottom of the cone is at x=10. A slice at depth x must be lifted x meters. Its height above the bottom is 10-x.

Use similar triangles to find the slice radius

The radius and height grow in the same ratio throughout the cone. Comparing the smaller triangle below the slice with the whole cone gives

r10-x=510r=10-x2

A thin horizontal slice is approximately a cylinder with area πr2 and thickness Δx. Substitute the radius to get its volume, mass, and weight.

ΔV≈π4(10-x)2ΔxΔm≈250π(10-x)2ΔxΔF≈2450π(10-x)2Δx

Multiply by the lifting distance and integrate

The lifting distance is x, so one slice needs approximately 2450πx(10-x)2Δx joules of work. Add these contributions over the water, then let the slice thickness approach zero. The sum becomes

W=2450π∫310x(10-x)2dx

Expand the polynomial and take an antiderivative.

W=2450π∫310(100x-20x2+x3)dx=2450π[50x2-20x33+x44]310

Evaluate the bracket at 10 and subtract its value at 3.

W=2450π(25003-11614)=7983325π6≈4.18×106

The work required to pump the water over the rim is approximately 4.18×106 joules.